Yes, I know another post on the AudioTraffic project… and it is still little more than a figment of my imagination at the moment - and no-one reads my blog anyway!
Since I’ve switched over to a Mac, I’ve been looking around for a suitable mp3 player that will sync with my Creative muvo m3 player, download podcasts and generally manage my music collection. Although I’m a mac user, I’m an open source fan and have been looking for other programs that will achieve the same aims I have for AudioTraffic. This would be great as it would mean that I don’t have to write the damn thing! Through this post I found through Planet Ubuntu I re-discovered the Songbird project.
I remember hearing about Songbird quite some time ago, and was initially quite impressed by it, but the development was way to slow and I lost interest. Now is a good time to go back and re-visit it. After only 10 minutes of messing around with it I have come to the following conclusion:
What I like about Songbird: A nice simple GUI (basically a black iTunes) - I might even consider some of the ideas here with AudioTraffic. Internet Radio - very cool and will please many, but I don’t really need this. RSS (MP3 Blogs) - thank goodness they didn’t call them podcasts! Network Device - again I don’t need this really (although it sounds very cool)
What I don’t like - (although many features are available the important one isn’t): Device syncing not yet supported. There are way too many features in this project, and that does put me off. After several years of things like song ratings, I just cannot see the point. I don’t like the way that the mp3 blogs works, Apples iTunes is much better in this point.
Basically, I find that there are way to many things included that I just won’t use and the things I need, (although planned) aren’t yet included. It will continue to piss me off that the stuff I don’t need will just take up pixel space and piss me off. Another thing, the this is a rubbish way to manage rss and mp3 blogs. However, I must start to consider that this is a browser based music managing program.
So would I completely switch to using Songbird if the features I wanted were included? Probably not, this is a browser based program, and I don’t think thats the right platform for this kind of thing. However, I am totally impressed by this software, and by the time I’ve got AudioTraffic up and running and I’ve been using it for a year, I expect that it’ll be time to switch over to Songbird. It all depends in which direction their project goes.
One last thing… Nik Butler also mentions Banshee as well as Songbird. Where is the Mac OS X version !!!